GemHausNew report

Tarrytown, NY 10591 Real Estate Market Report

ZIP Code: 10591
Report Date: May 2026
Market Temperature: HOT
Scope: This ZIP code analysis focuses on single-family residential (SFR) properties. Metrics are calculated from recent sales and active listings within the past 90 days.


Market Overview

This analysis is based on a sample of properties from this ZIP code (up to 200 sold properties and up to 100 active properties). The median prices below are calculated from all available properties in the sample, while trend analysis uses properties from the selected analysis window.

Analysis Window
90 Days
Total Properties Analyzed
21
Active Listings
15
Sold Properties
6

Market Metrics

Median Listing Price
$1,499,000
Median Sold Price
$1,000,000
Median Price per Sqft
$520/sqft

Note: The property counts shown above represent only the properties analyzed in this report sample, not the total inventory for this ZIP code. Median prices are calculated from all available properties in the sample, while trend analysis uses properties from the selected analysis window.


Rental Market

Median Market Rent
$3,200

Note: The relationship between property values and rental rates reflects different market dynamics. Higher-priced properties may have lower rental yields due to factors such as luxury market positioning, owner-occupancy preferences, or long-term appreciation strategies rather than immediate rental income maximization.


Liquidity & Velocity

Median Days on Market
345
Sale-to-List Ratio
100.0%

Note: A Sale-to-List Ratio near 100% can occur when properties sell at or near their final listing price after price adjustments during the listing period, even when initial listing prices differ significantly from sale prices.


Market Trends & Context

Understanding Market Temperature

A Hot market indicates strong buyer demand with limited inventory, typically characterized by rising prices, quick sales (low days on market), and inventory levels below historical averages.

Price YoY Trend
down
Market Temperature
hot
Rent YoY Trend
up
Interest Rate Pressure
elevated

Current Mortgage Rate Context

Market-level mortgage rate comparison for this area:

Current 30-year fixed mortgage rates in Tarrytown, NY are 6.4% compared to the 5.9% average seen earlier in 2026, indicating that property owners who secured loans during that period locked in a more favorable rate.

Note: Interest rate comparisons provide market context. The existing "Interest Rate Pressure" metric above shows the qualitative market impact.


Key Findings

  1. The neighborhood’s primary market signal is the median sold price of $1,000,000, which represents the most reliable indicator of recent transaction value and should be prioritized over asking prices when setting comps and advising sellers.

  2. There is clear pricing friction between the median listing price of $1,499,000 and the median sold price, which may indicate seller expectations exceeding realized transaction values and suggests down pressure on achievable sale prices.

  3. Market velocity appears slow relative to typical hot markets: the median days on market of 345 points to extended sale timelines and may indicate reduced liquidity despite broader demand signals; this suggests pricing or condition adjustments may be needed to accelerate transactions.

  4. Fundamental demand and financing context are mixed: the market is characterized as hot with rents up (median market rent of $3,200), but faces elevated interest rate pressure (current rate context ~6.4% vs. prior 5.9%), so buyers may be active yet affordability-constrained—position listings to capture motivated buyers and highlight financing strategies.


Notable Properties

The following 8 properties represent notable market examples and recent transactions that illustrate key market dynamics. These are illustrative examples selected for their significance (top sales, market benchmarks, quick sales) and are not the basis for the statistical calculations shown above.

Recent Transactions

10 Powder Horn Way, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Top Sale

Highest sale in the past 90 days. Fully renovated with modern finishes and premium lot positioning.

5 beds
4 baths
3,104 sqft
$1,825,000
Mar 1, 2026
$588/sqft/sqft
251 Kelbourne Ave, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591
Premium

Sold above market average

3 beds
3 baths
2,388 sqft
$1,660,000
Feb 1, 2026
$695/sqft/sqft
219 days on market
29 Dixon St, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Premium

Sold above market average

3 beds
3 baths
1,582 sqft
$1,290,000
Feb 1, 2026
$815/sqft/sqft
179 days on market
443 Benedict Ave, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Premium

Sold above market average

4 beds
1 baths
950 sqft
$700,000
Feb 1, 2026
$737/sqft/sqft
182 days on market
443 Benedict Ave, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Premium

Sold above market average

4 beds
1 baths
950 sqft
$700,000
Feb 1, 2026
$737/sqft/sqft
182 days on market
43 Putnam Ave, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Value

Sold below market average

3 beds
1 baths
1,473 sqft
$607,600
Apr 1, 2026
$412/sqft/sqft
233 days on market
43 Putnam Ave, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Value

Sold below market average

3 beds
1 baths
1,473 sqft
$607,600
Apr 1, 2026
$412/sqft/sqft
233 days on market
9 Eunice Ct, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Value

Sold below market average

- beds
2 baths
1,256 sqft
$500,000
Mar 1, 2026
$398/sqft/sqft

Tarrytown, NY 10591 Real Estate Market Report

ZIP Code: 10591
Report Date: May 2026
Market Temperature: HOT
Scope: This ZIP code analysis focuses on condominium properties. Metrics are calculated from recent condo sales and active listings within the past 90 days.


Market Overview

This analysis is based on a sample of properties from this ZIP code (up to 200 sold properties and up to 100 active properties). The median prices below are calculated from all available properties in the sample, while trend analysis uses properties from the selected analysis window.

Analysis Window
90 Days
Total Properties Analyzed
14
Active Listings
8
Sold Properties
6

Market Metrics

Median Listing Price
$1,907,500
Median Sold Price
$700,000
Median Price per Sqft
$682/sqft

Note: The property counts shown above represent only the properties analyzed in this report sample, not the total inventory for this ZIP code. Median prices are calculated from all available properties in the sample, while trend analysis uses properties from the selected analysis window.


Rental Market

Median Market Rent
$2,550

Note: The relationship between property values and rental rates reflects different market dynamics. Higher-priced properties may have lower rental yields due to factors such as luxury market positioning, owner-occupancy preferences, or long-term appreciation strategies rather than immediate rental income maximization.


Liquidity & Velocity

Median Days on Market
415
Sale-to-List Ratio
100.0%

Note: A Sale-to-List Ratio near 100% can occur when properties sell at or near their final listing price after price adjustments during the listing period, even when initial listing prices differ significantly from sale prices.


Market Trends & Context

Understanding Market Temperature

A Hot market indicates strong buyer demand with limited inventory, typically characterized by rising prices, quick sales (low days on market), and inventory levels below historical averages.

Price YoY Trend
down
Market Temperature
hot
Rent YoY Trend
up
Interest Rate Pressure
elevated

Current Mortgage Rate Context

Market-level mortgage rate comparison for this area:

Current 30-year fixed mortgage rates in Tarrytown, NY are 6.4% compared to the 5.9% average seen earlier in 2026, indicating that property owners who secured loans during that period locked in a more favorable rate.

Note: Interest rate comparisons provide market context. The existing "Interest Rate Pressure" metric above shows the qualitative market impact.


Key Findings

  1. median sold price $700,000 is the primary indicator of recent market value in 10591 and points to realized transaction pricing that is substantially lower than current asking levels; this gap suggests pricing friction between seller expectations and closed sales.

  2. median listing price $1,907,500 contrasts sharply with settled transactions, which may indicate elevated seller price aspirations relative to recently achieved sale prices and downward pressure on reported prices.

  3. median days on market 415 signals materially slower sales velocity and suggests that, despite a reported hot market temperature, liquidity appears stretched with prolonged time-to-contract for listed homes.

  4. median price per square foot $682 and median market rent $2,550 combined with a upward rent year-over-year trend imply rental demand strength; however, elevated interest rate pressure remains a headwind (elevated) and may constrain owner-occupier affordability despite strong rental fundamentals.


Notable Properties

The following 2 properties represent notable market examples and recent transactions that illustrate key market dynamics. These are illustrative examples selected for their significance (top sales, market benchmarks, quick sales) and are not the basis for the statistical calculations shown above.

Recent Transactions

119 River St, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591
Top Sale

Highest sale in the past 90 days. Fully renovated with modern finishes and premium lot positioning.

2 beds
2 baths
2,493 sqft
$1,710,000
Oct 1, 2025
$686/sqft/sqft
238 days on market
93 River St, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591
Value

Sold below market average

2 beds
2 baths
2,493 sqft
$1,350,000
Jun 1, 2025
$542/sqft/sqft
394 days on market

Investment Analysis

Compare rental income potential against ownership costs and benchmark against market averages.

Rent vs Cost to Own

Monthly rental income vs estimated ownership cost

-$2,960/mo
10591 Avg Rent
10591 Cost to Own
Rent$3,200
Own$6,160

20% down, 6.3% rate, 1.1% tax

Short-Term Rental

Avg nightly rate and occupancy for this ZIP

10591 Avg nightly rate
10591 Avg occupancy (days/year)
Nightly rate$208/night
Occupancy197 of 365 days

Data Sources

Real estate market data & public records, and GemHaus® proprietary models.

Report generated: 5/1/2026

GemHaus

Get personalized market intelligence

Unlock deeper property intel in Tarrytown, NY valuations, rent comps, operating costs, and pro-forma breakdowns.

Nearby Market Reports