Cash on Cash Return vs Cap Rate: Formulas + Examples

Cash on cash return shows what your own money earns. Cap rate helps compare similar properties. Formulas, a worked example with two rentals, and how to read each number.

GGemHausUpdated 6 min read
Abstract GemHaus cover: two fractions drawn as outlines on deep green, separated by a dotted line. Both have the same mint box on top, tagged INCOME. On the left it sits over a long dashed teal box tagged PRICE; on the right, over a short lime box tagged YOUR CASH.

TL;DR. Cash on cash return is the cash a rental leaves you in a year, divided by the cash you put in. Cap rate is the property's yearly income after running costs, divided by its price. It leaves the loan out. NOI is yearly rent minus running costs, before the loan. Yearly cash flow is rent minus running costs minus loan payments. Use cap rate to compare similar properties in the same market. Use cash on cash return to see what your own money earns after the loan.

Two formulas. Cash on cash return equals yearly cash flow divided by cash invested, and counts the loan. Cap rate equals yearly NOI divided by property price, and leaves the loan out.

The two numbers side by side

MeasureCash on cash returnCap rate
FormulaYearly cash flow ÷ cash investedYearly NOI ÷ property price
The question it answersWhat does my cash earn?How much does this property earn compared with its price?
Counts the loan?YesNo
Changes with your down payment?YesNo
Best forJudging your own dealComparing similar properties
Range cited by guides (illustrative)8% to 12% (Hemlane)OfferMarket: 4% to 8% for residential rentals. RentSpree: 5% to 8% for single-family

The ranges are illustrative. They come from public guides (one for cash on cash return, two for cap rate), not from GemHaus, and they are not a promise or a target. See "What is a good cap rate?" and "What is a good cash on cash return?" below.

What are you trying to do?

If you want to...Look at
Compare two properties no matter how you payCap rate
See what your down payment earns after the loanCash on cash return
Estimate what is left each monthMonthly cash flow
Check whether a number is "good"The illustrative ranges
Avoid misreading the numbersThe four ways to misread them

Cash on cash return

What cash on cash return is

Cash on cash return is the yearly cash a rental leaves you, as a percent of the cash you put in. It tells you what your own money earns each year. The loan payments count as a cost, and your cash, not the price, is what you divide by.

The formula

Cash on cash return = yearly cash flow ÷ total cash invested

Yearly cash flow is rent minus running costs minus the loan payments, over 12 months. Total cash invested is your down payment plus closing costs plus any repairs you pay for before renting.

Worked example: two rentals

These two rentals and their costs are made up. Each is bought with 20% down and a 30-year loan at 7.11%. The 7.11% is the Freddie Mac 30-year fixed-rate average as of 12 November 2026 (accessed November 2026). It covers conventional, conforming loans to buy an owner-occupied single-family home, so it is not a quote for any loan and rental loans may price differently. Freddie Mac updates this average weekly, usually on Thursdays. Mortgage rates change every week, so this example will age. Closing costs are 3% of the price. Costs are 8% of rent for management, 10% for maintenance and 5% for vacancy. The example leaves out utilities, HOA fees and reserves.

Two made-up rentals. 30-year loan at 7.11% (Freddie Mac average as of 12 November 2026), 20% down, 3% closing costs.
ItemRental ARental B
Price$250,000$200,000
Rent$2,000 a month ($24,000 a year)$2,100 a month ($25,200 a year)
Property tax a year$3,000$2,400
Insurance a year$1,500$1,200
Management (8% of rent)$1,920$2,016
Maintenance (10% of rent)$2,400$2,520
Vacancy (5% of rent)$1,200$1,260
Running costs a year$10,020$9,396
NOI (rent minus running costs)$13,980$15,804
Down payment (20%)$50,000$40,000
Closing costs (3%)$7,500$6,000
Cash invested$57,500$46,000
Loan$200,000$160,000
Loan payment a month$1,345.41$1,076.33
Loan payments a year$16,145$12,916
Cash flow a year (NOI minus loan payments)−$2,165 (−$180 a month)+$2,888 (+$241 a month)
Cash on cash return−3.8%6.3%
Cap rate (NOI ÷ price)5.6%7.9%

Rental A's math: $13,980 NOI − $16,145 loan payments = −$2,165 a year. Divide by $57,500 cash invested and you get −3.8%.

Rental B's math: $15,804 NOI − $12,916 loan payments = $2,888 a year. Divide by $46,000 and you get 6.3%.

Rental A has a cap rate of 5.6%, inside OfferMarket's 4% to 8% range for residential rentals (accessed November 2026). With this loan it still loses money. The loan payments ($16,145) are bigger than the property's NOI ($13,980), so the cash flow is negative.

Now buy Rental A with no loan. Cash invested is $257,500 ($250,000 plus $7,500 closing costs). Cash on cash return is $13,980 ÷ $257,500, or 5.4%. Same property, same rent, and the return moves from −3.8% to 5.4% because the loan changed. This is the effect of this loan at this rate. It is not a reason to borrow or not to borrow. The no-loan return is below the cap rate because of the $7,500 closing costs.

Worked example. Bar chart titled: Cap rate leaves the loan out. Cash on cash return counts it. Legend: Cap rate; Cash on cash return, with a loan; Cash on cash return, no loan. Two made-up rentals. Rental A: cap rate 5.6%; cash on cash return −3.8% with a loan, shown below the 0% line, and 5.4% with no loan. A note next to the negative bar says: Same property, same rent. Only the loan changed. Rental B: cap rate 7.9%; cash on cash return 6.3% with a loan. Footnote: Illustrative. Made-up inputs; loan rate 7.11% (Freddie Mac 30-year average, as of 2026-11-12). Not a forecast or advice.

Cap rate

What cap rate is

Cap rate is a property's yearly income after running costs, as a percent of its price. It ignores the loan. Two investors who buy the same property get the same cap rate, even if one pays cash and the other borrows.

The formula, and what NOI means

Cap rate = NOI ÷ property price (or value)

NOI means net operating income. It is a year of rent minus a year of running costs: property tax, insurance, management, maintenance, vacancy and the utilities you pay. NOI leaves out the loan payments.

In the example, Rental A earns $13,980 of NOI on a $250,000 price. That is 5.6%. Rental B earns $15,804 on $200,000, or 7.9%.

Cap rate vs cash on cash return

When to use cap rate

Best for: comparing similar properties. Cap rate takes the loan out, so two properties compare on what they earn, not on how each buyer pays. It says nothing about your down payment, your rate or your cash. A strong cap rate does not mean a property fits your plan.

When to use cash on cash return

Best for: judging your own deal. Cash on cash return uses your loan and your cash, so it changes when your down payment or rate changes. It covers one year only. It counts every loan payment as a cost, even though part of each payment builds your equity, the share of the property you own outright.

When to use monthly cash flow

Best for: estimating what is left each month. Cash flow is rent minus running costs minus the loan payment, per month. In the example, Rental A is about −$180 a month. Our guide to how to calculate cash flow on a rental property goes step by step.

For a longer look at the cap rate alone, see Cap rate explained.

What is a good cap rate?

There is no definitive good cap rate. Two public guides give ranges. RentSpree (updated April 2025) lists single-family rentals at 5% to 8% and multifamily at 4% to 7%, and says the multifamily range represents primary markets with good demand. OfferMarket (accessed November 2026) lists residential rentals at 4% to 8%, residential multifamily at 4% to 6% and Airbnb at 8% or higher, calls its table "very broad generalizations", and says it is even less sure about the Airbnb figure. Both say a higher cap rate can come with more risk. These ranges are illustrative, apply only to the property types each guide names, and do not predict what any property will earn. Multifamily means a building with several rental units.

Property typeRange one guide citesSource
Single-family rental5% to 8%RentSpree, 2025 edition
Residential rental4% to 8%OfferMarket, accessed November 2026
Multifamily4% to 7% (primary markets)RentSpree, 2025 edition
Residential multifamily4% to 6%OfferMarket, accessed November 2026

Illustrative. These are ranges from two public guides. They are not GemHaus figures, they do not predict what any property will earn, and they are not advice.

Sources: RentSpree and OfferMarket.

Two guides can disagree, as these do on multifamily. OfferMarket's own text also says that, generalizing quite a bit, a cap rate of 7% or higher is considered a good one. A higher cap rate is not always better. It does not show why the number is high or low: the building's condition, the area, risk and the loan are not in the formula. A property can sit inside a typical range and still lose money, as Rental A does.

What is a good cash on cash return?

There is no official good cash on cash return either. One guide, Hemlane, says that as a general rule 8% to 12% is a good range for a worthwhile investment property, and adds that it depends on the investor's goals.

Illustrative. A rule of thumb from one public guide (Hemlane, last updated March 2026). It is not a GemHaus target, it does not predict what any property will earn, and it is not advice.

What counts as good depends on your cash, your loan rate and what else you could do with the money. In the example, Rental B returns 6.3% and Rental A returns −3.8%. Both sit below the 8% to 12% rule of thumb. The rule is a reference point, not a verdict on any property. Compare cash on cash return across properties with the same kind of loan, since a different down payment changes the number.

Four ways to misread the numbers

  1. Leaving out costs. Vacancy, repairs, management and the utilities you pay all cut NOI. Leave them out and both numbers rise.
  2. Using the asking rent. Check the rent against comparable rentals nearby. A rent that is too high flatters NOI, cap rate and cash on cash return.
  3. Counting only the down payment. Cash invested includes closing costs and any repairs you pay for before renting. Leave them out and cash on cash return rises.
  4. Treating one as the other. A 5.6% cap rate is not a 5.6% return on your cash.

Analyze a property in GemHaus

Run this on a property you are looking at. Your first estimate is free. The full report shows cash flow, cap rate and cash on cash, and it opens with credits or Unlimited.

Analyze a property

Free: your first estimate. Full report with cash flow, cap rate and cash on cash: credits or Unlimited. No credit card to sign up.

GemHaus gives estimates, not promises. People still decide, and still walk the property.

This page is for education. It is not financial, tax or investment advice. The examples are made up.

Frequently Asked Questions

G

GemHaus

Share

Continue reading